Week 24  ethics and aesthetics

Author and Hero Metaphor

   – Ethical Dimension: The author’s responsibility to the hero mirrors our ethical responsibility to others. We help shape each other’s identities through our interactions, highlighting the ethical duty to engage with and respect others.

   – Aesthetic Dimension: Just as an author crafts a narrative, we co-create the “story” of our lives with others, making identity formation an aesthetic process of meaning-making.

Importance of Dialogue

   – Ethical Dimension: Engaging in dialogue with others means acknowledging and valuing their perspectives, which is a key ethical practice.

   – Aesthetic Dimension: Dialogue enriches the aesthetic quality of our lives, making our identities more nuanced, complex, and meaningful.

Birth and Death Metaphors:

   – Ethical Dimension: Understanding that we help “birth” each other’s identities through our interactions highlights the ethical responsibility we have in how we influence and shape others.

   – Aesthetic Dimension: The idea of continuous “birth” and the open-ended nature of our identities emphasize that life is an ongoing aesthetic creation, where we continually shape and reshape meaning until the end.

Ethics and Aesthetics Intertwined:

   – The fusion of ethics (how we treat and engage with others) and aesthetics (how we create and interpret meaning) shows that living a meaningful life involves both ethical responsibility and creative engagement with the world and others.

Dynamic Identity:

   – Ethical Dimension: Recognizing that identity is dynamic encourages a more compassionate and open approach to ourselves and others, fostering ethical relationships.

   – Aesthetic Dimension: Viewing identity as a continuous, evolving process highlights the creative, aesthetic journey of becoming, shaped by the rich tapestry of our interactions.

Week 23 A global sense of a place

Time-Space Compression

– The world feels smaller due to globalization and technological advancements (e.g. emails, fast travel, media streaming).

– Our experience of space and place has changed; distance and time are compressed.

Not Everyone Experiences It Equally

– Massey highlights “power-geometry”: some people have more control and mobility (e.g. business travelers), while others are stuck or negatively affected (e.g. factory workers, refugees).

– Factors like gender, race, and class affect how people experience mobility and space. 

  – Example: Women’s mobility may be limited due to safety concerns.

Digital Communities and Fluid Identities

– You brought up how online communities help people stay connected across borders (e.g. staying in touch with your hometown while living elsewhere).

– This reflects a fluid and dynamic sense of place, shaped by relationships rather than fixed geography.

Cultural Mixing and Global Influence

– You mentioned how living in Hong Kong exposed you to multiple cultures from a young age, showing how a place can be shaped by colonial history and global exchanges.

– This reflects Massey’s idea that **places are made through global connections**, not just local heritage.

Globalization and Inequality

– Unequal mobility can reinforce social inequality.

  – Example: A car owner has more mobility than someone relying on public transport, which gets underfunded.

– Digital access and remote work can expand freedom for some, but not everyone has equal access.

A Progressive Sense of Place

– Massey argues for a “global sense of the local”—seeing places not as isolated, but as intersections of global social relations.

– Places are processes, not fixed containers.

– A sense of place can be inclusive, outward-looking, and connected—not nostalgic or reactionary.

Safety and Mobility for Women

– You gave an example of a friend in South Africa who faces threats walking alone—showing how place is gendered.

Spring break

Spring break is the perfect time to rest and recharge, especially after a stressful second year at university.

Unit 2 has been overwhelming, and I’ve felt burned out. There were a lot of conflicts and issues in my course, which created a mental burden and made me feel unsafe at times. Not everyone seemed happy, and that added to the stress. I had to juggle a ton of assignments and respond to countless messages from my cohort, which was exhausting. Honestly, I often didn’t want to collaborate with others-I just wanted to focus on my own work. While I learned a lot about teamwork, it’s not my strength, and I prefer doing things my way without compromising.

As an artist, I also struggle with feedback, whether it’s positive or negative. I want my work to reflect who I am, not be shaped by others’ opinions. Group activities, meetings, and exchanging ideas with classmates weren’t enjoyable for me this year, maybe because I’m feeling more independent.

That’s why spring break was such a great opportunity to take a step back and relax. I also got the chance to pitch my card game to a board game company, which was an exciting and valuable experience. It’s my first time creating a board game, and I’d love to work on it more when I have free time. Overall, I enjoyed spring break so much more than my Unit 2 of university. Unit 2 has been a tough experience compared to Unit 2.